Perspectives on Rising Depression and Anxiety
Among Teens and Young Adults
Why It’s Happening and What Can Be Done About It
Instances of severe depression and anxiety have been increasingly
upsetting the lives of teenagers and young adults in the twenty-first
century. The reporting and research on this topic over the past several
years reveals a continuous, multi-level cautionary tale about the
seriousness of troubling times young people are experiencing today in
record numbers.
An October 2016 Time magazine cover story — “Teen Depression and
Anxiety: Why the Kids Are Not Alright” — paints a picture of millions of
teens feeling severe anxiety and stress from an amalgamation of too
much schoolwork, social media hyper connectedness and bullying,
career goal pressure, complex college application and financial aid
processes, climate change worries and woes, sexism, racism,
terrorism, school shootings, poverty, inequality, intolerance, ad
nausea.
The Time cover story features data from the National Institute of
Mental Health showing that 6.3 million kids have had an anxiety
disorder, adding that such numbers are likely much higher, as only
about 20% of young people with severe anxiety disorder get any kind
of treatment.
From High School to College
By the time they reach college, nothing much has changed, with
depression and anxiety numbers still on the rise. “Record Numbers of
College Students Are Seeking Treatment for Depression and Anxiety —
But Schools Can’t Keep Up,” shouts a March 2018 Time article in which
several sobering statistics are presented.
•
Students visiting with counselors increased by 30% between 2009
and 2015.
•
In a spring 2017 survey of 63,000 college students at 92 schools,
40% acknowledged they had problems functioning and 61% said
they “felt overwhelming anxiety.”
•
2,700 UCLA students enrolled in an online screening test on
depression that resulted in 250 identified as at-risk for severe
depression, mania, or suicidal thoughts.
•
Pennsylvania State University approved a $700,000 budget
increase for psychological services due to what they called a
“dramatic increase” in demands for more student counseling
services over the past decade.
•
College counseling centers nationwide are overwhelmed. “The
average university has one professional counselor for every 1,737
students — fewer than the minimum of one therapist for every
1,000 to 1,500 students recommended by the International
Association of Counseling Services.”
A September 2019 article in the Philadelphia Inquirer reports on a
heartbreaking tragedy related to college mental health counseling
services. Six months after being hired, the executive director of
counseling and psychological services at the University of
Pennsylvania — a highly respected professional with 15 years of
experience serving students — committed suicide. Sadly, the
university has seen 14 student suicides since 2013.
According to a 2019 report by the Center for Disease Control (CDC),
U.S. suicide rates in 2017 were 33% higher than in 1999. Non-Hispanic
American Indian or Alaska Native persons had the highest suicide
rates for both females and males aged 15–24 and 25–44.
A June 2019 American Medical Association research letter highlights
trends in suicide death rates at ages 15–19 and 20–24. For both age
groups the suicide rates “increased in 2017 to its highest point since
2000, with a recent increase especially in males and in ages 15 to 19.”
Why Depression is On the Rise
Reading through some of the research and expert opinions on this
topic helps to provide a keener understanding of why all this is
happening and what can be done about it. However, it’s also very
important to recognize that mental health issues are enormously
complex, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution and plenty of trial
and error research geared toward discovering solutions that have yet
to be discovered.
For an in-depth, base-line resource that helps to answer the why
question, see a 2012 paper titled “Depression as a disease of
modernity: explanations for increasing prevalence,” by Brandon
Hidaka, MD, PhD. Hidaka provides a review of the research, focusing
his efforts on cross-cultural studies on depression. He claims that the
past century has brought about drastic changes in our daily lives that
have fueled “diseases of modernity,” such as atherosclerosis,
hormone-related and gastrointestinal cancers, diabetes, and excess
depression and anxiety.
“Evidence suggests we may indeed be in the midst of an epidemic of
depression,” he writes, with young people having a higher risk of
depression than their parents and grandparents.
What are some common modern-day causes of depression in teens
and young adults (other than tragic life events such as loss of a loved
one, serious illness, sexual abuse, and other negative fateful events
beyond one’s control)? Many seem obvious if we take the time to fully
recognize and closely examine how many of our daily habits have long-
term negative effects on mental health. For instance, Hidaka points to
the decline of physical well-being as a major contributor to depression.
Overindulging in high-sugar, high-fat, high-calorie, and refined and fast
foods, along with a sedentary lifestyle, brings on unnecessary weight
gain, obesity, and poor body image, resulting in psychological distress
and oftentimes severe depression. The CDC reports that “during
2013–2016, approximately 37% of adults consumed fast food on a
given day.”
Other physical well-being aspects of our lives that tend to induce
depression include not getting enough sleep and not getting enough
sunlight due to being indoors too frequently.
Additionally, Hidaka cites research demonstrating a cultural shift
“away from intrinsic goals, e.g. social relationships, community, and
competence, to extrinsic goals, like money, status, and appearance.”
Such cultural shifting typically coincides with increased incidences of
loneliness and isolation among teens and young adults.
And it’s no secret that isolation and loneliness, which can still occur if
your social connections are large in quantity but lack in qualitative
substance, are exacerbated through an unhealthy over-reliance on
online social media networks and other Internet-based
communications as opposed to face-to-face interactions.
To bolster such claims, a September 2019 Experimental Economics
journal paper on a study of 1,769 U.S. undergrads found that “a one-
week Facebook restriction decreased feelings of depression and
increased engagement in healthier activities.”
Lastly, Hidaka references several studies that show accumulating
evidence indicating “that the social environment in modern-
industrialized countries, especially in the United States, has become
increasingly competitive, threatening, and socially isolating,” with
“increased competition most obvious in college admissions and
economically, as populations now compete for jobs on a global scale.”
He also mentions research on the so-called paradox of choice (too
many options) so prevalent today, noting that “excessive choice can
lead to paralytic indecision, greater expectations, stress, and eventual
dissatisfaction, blame and regret.”
A Journalist on a Mission with a Relatively Simple Solution
UK journalist and author of “Lost Connections: Uncovering the Real
Causes of Depression — and the Unexpected Solutions” Johann Hari
offers a sensible overview on depression and anxiety in his book and
in a July 2019 Ted Summit, titled “This could be why you’re depressed
and anxious,” that has more than 1.3 million views. The 40-year-old
Hari tells of his own lifelong battle with mental health issues and his
sincere and deep desire to understand why so many people are getting
depressed. He researched his book by traveling over 40,000 miles
around the world interviewing numerous high-level experts about the
causes and solutions of depression.
Hari concludes that while some people have biological causes of
depression that definitely require taking antidepressants, “most of the
factors that have been proven to cause depression are not in our
biology. They are factors in the way we live.” Hari adds that he
personally took the highest legal doses of antidepressants possible for
13 years, and yet, “for a lot of those 13 years, and pretty much all of
the time at the end, I was still in a lot of pain.”
Factors that induce depression and anxiety outside of biology that
Hari features include feeling lonely, working at a job you have no
control over, rarely communing with nature, feeling that your life has
no real meaning or purpose, and believing your outlook for the future
does not make any good sense. These are the kind of negative
psychological aspects of life, Hari believes, that do not require
antidepressants to fix. “If you’re depressed, if you’re anxious, you’re
not weak, you’re not crazy, you’re not, in the main, a machine with
broken parts,” he says. “You’re a human with unmet needs.”
So, the question becomes how can we overcome unmet needs? “It’s
not like rocket science,” Hari answers. It’s recognizing that depression
is more than likely a signal — not a biological malfunction or a
weakness — that is telling people to seek out more meaning and
purpose in life.
How to Move Along a Life Path Towards Meaning and Purpose
Despite the relative simplicity of Hari’s answer, finding meaning and
purpose in life is much easier said than done, regardless of age and/or
one’s station in life. It’s more of a lifelong process with plenty of twists
and turns.
A unique January 2018 listicle article in Greater Good magazine
published by the Greater Good Science Center (GGSC) at the University
of California, Berkeley offers six ways to discover purpose in life. GGSC
online editor Jeremy Adam Smith writes that purpose “grows from our
connection to others, which is why a crisis of purpose is often a
symptom of isolation.” The six ways are:
1.
Read — Studies show that adolescents who frequently read both
secular and non-secular books that interest them have a stronger
sense of purpose.
2.
Turn hurts into healing for others — People who are willing to
share experiences of suffering with others facing similar
circumstances often find a correspondingly related purpose to
pursue in life.
3.
Cultivate awe, gratitude, and altruism — Research shows that
those who count their blessings are more likely to contribute to
the greater good, which is a sure way to have more meaning and
purpose in life.
4.
Listen to what other people appreciate about you — “Gratitude
strengthens relationships — and those are often the source of our
purpose.”
5.
Find and build community — Seek out inspiration in the people
around you and try to discover commonalities among each other
that can result in making a positive difference in your community.
6.
Tell your story — Writing about your life journey (your narrative)
with a focus on challenges, growth and inner strengths can help
bring more clarity about your authentic self and put you on a
sensible and strong path toward more meaning and purpose in
your life.
In a December 2017 Great Good magazine article, Amy L. Eva, Ph.D.,
associate education director at GGSC, presents three research-based
strategies for adults to support and engage in with youth who face
roadblocks due to stress, poverty, and systemic racism and intolerance
as they attempt to embark on purposeful life trajectories. They are:
1.
Communicate high expectations — Showing that you firmly
believe in a young person’s potential for growth increases their
chances for success.
2.
Be invested and accessible — When adults take a keen and sincere
interest in supporting a young person’s life goals, they typically
become energized and increasingly motivated.
3.
Facilitate self-exploration — Talk about inspirational people and
quotes related to meaning and purpose and relate them to a teen
or young adult’s personal life. “Even a brief, 45-minute discussion
of purpose, values, and interests can increase the sense of
purpose that students feel.”
Writer’s Note: When you come right down to it, in my opinion (and I’m not
a professional counselor by any means), none of these meaning and
purpose-oriented suggestions are overly esoteric or difficult to understand.
Like Hari says, “it’s not like rocket science.” At the same time, diagnosing
mental health is highly individualistic and not an exact science, and
effective treatments are often illusive. It seems to be more of a matter of
not giving up, regardless of how many failures, obstacles and setbacks
might come into play, and consistently experimenting with different
strategies, until a genuine love of life and a straight-on focus and
movement toward reaching goals and aspirations kicks in on a more solid
and permanent basis.
“Oh, sure, we have
another world war
coming, and
another great
depression, but
where are the
leaders this time?”
- Kurt Vonnegut